Why Your Take Home Pay Looks Messed Up

Payroll check stub

Photo by Christopher Titzer

The number one question I’m getting these days (okay, besides how big will my refund be?) is “What happened to my take home pay?”  Hopefully, I’ve got some answers for you.

We’ve all heard that Congress voted not to increase our payroll taxes, but it looks like there’s more federal withholding being taken out of your paycheck.  What’s up with that?  Well, the income tax rate didn’t go up, but the “Making Work Pay” credit was taken out.  Because that credit it gone, your payroll withholding has gone up (somewhere between $400 and $800 per year depending on your filing status.)

The other change that we’ve heard about is that the Social Security withholding went down from 6.2% to 4.2%.  This makes your payroll withholding go down.  Depending upon how much you make, this might give you more take home pay than before, for others, it’s the opposite.  (Here’s a clue, the more money you make, the bigger this deduction will seem.)

If you get a pension, and not wages, the increase in the withholding will hit you harder because you don’t have social security withholding.

Now for many people, the payroll tax changes were not set up correctly for their first paychecks of the year.  Please don’t blame your payroll department; the changes came so late in the year, that computer programs were not programmed for the new rules.  This made for some crazy adjustments that showed up in later checks.  Hopefully, by now, your paycheck should be normal.

It’s always a good idea to check to make sure your payroll withholding is right.  The IRS has a withholding calculator that you can use to see if you’re on target for next tax season.  You might want to wait another week or so to make sure that all of the payroll adjustments are done and that you’ve got a “normal” check to look at before running the numbers through the calculator.  If you use a check with “adjustments” in it, the numbers will be crazy so make sure you’ve got at least two checks in a row that have the same withholding numbers in them.

2 thoughts on “Why Your Take Home Pay Looks Messed Up

  1. Hey firozsayal,
    I had trashed your previous post because you’re from England. But it seems I’m getting a bunch of readers from your side of the pond so I thought I’d leave your withholding calculator up for them.
    Americans, should go to the IRS website. Brits–go visit firozsayal. Remember, my website is only good for US taxes. If you don’t need to be paying US income tax, this isn’t the right website for you. But thanks for visiting.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.